(713) 352-7975

Back To Blog

Personal Injury Cases: What Happens in “He Said, She Said” Situations?

What Happens in "He Said, She Said" Situations?
What Happens in “He Said, She Said” Situations?

“He said, she said” disputes can be the basis of nearly any type of personal injury case. That’s because, when one party accuses another of negligence and causing harm, the accused party often has a different story as part of his or her defense case.

When conflicting stories about what occurred and who’s liable arise in personal injury cases, resolving these “he said, she said” disputes typically relies on finding and presenting evidence that:

  • Supports one version of the story
  • Discredits the other version.

Revealing more, the following points out the specific factors that can be used to resolve personal injury claims based on “he said, she said” disputes.

Have You or a Loved One Been Hurt by Another’s Negligent Actions?

Call (713) 352-7975 or Email Our Firm
for a Free, Confidential, No Obligation Case Evaluation

During your FREE consultation, we will explain your legal options. Free virtual and mobile consultations are available to anyone who cannot visit our offices.

4 Factors Crucial to “He Said, She Said” Personal Injury Cases

  1. The credibility of each party in the claim – When conflicting stories about the incident at the heart of a personal injury claim are presented, credibility plays a big role. Determining which version is the most credible can involve:
    • Examining the background and character of each party – Specifically, does either party have a history of fraud, criminal activities, or other behaviors that can throw his or her credibility into question?
    • Looking at the consistency of the allegations over time – Has either party’s story changed at any point? Do the details of either side’s story seem to make sense, or do they raise more questions?
    • Evaluating the attitude and demeanor of each party – Do the body language, tone, and expression seem to align with the story being told? Or do they betray some deception by either party?

  2. The statements and credibility of other witnesses – If there are witnesses (other than the parties involved in the claim) that observed the incident, evaluating their statements and credibility can also be key to resolving “he said, she said” personal injury cases. As part of this evaluation, it’s important to assess the neutrality of each third-party witness and how their stories do or do not line up with the allegations in the case.

  3. The physical evidence – This type of evidence can go a long way towards backing up or refuting the accusations in a personal injury case. Depending on the nature of the case, physical evidence can include (and is not limited to) photographs, surveillance video footage, debris from an accident, tire tread marks (in car crash cases), and more.

  4. The legal representation for each party in the claim – The plaintiff and defense lawyers involved in a personal injury case can also play a big role in how “he said, she said” claims are resolved. That’s because the right attorney can conduct further investigations, work to find more evidence to support a case, find additional credible witnesses (like expert witnesses), and effectively present the arguments and evidence in any legal setting. When there’s no “smoking gun” that clearly supports or refutes the allegations in a case, the representation of an experienced lawyer can make all of the difference in how strong and successful that case is when it’s time to resolve the dispute.

Position Your Claim for Success: Contact a Houston Personal Injury Attorney at the Amaro Law Firm

If you or a loved one has been harmed by another party’s negligent or reckless actions, don’t hesitate to contact a Houston personal injury attorney at the Amaro Law Firm. We are ready to partner with you, protect and advance your claim, and help you navigate the road to recovery and justice.

Call (713) 352-7975 or Email Us for your FREE Consultation.

At the Amaro Law Firm, our experienced personal injury attorneys are known for exceptional representation, personal service, and outstanding results. We know how to stand up to big companies, insurance companies, and others, protecting our clients’ rights while working relentlessly to secure the best outcomes possible. Our long-standing record of success and superior advocacy has earned us a 5-star rating on Google and Facebook, the top rating on Avvo, and glowing testimonials from former clients.